Skip to content
World edition
Analyst Newspaper
World · Multi-perspective analysis

Indian Flydubai pilot hailed as hero after cockpit attack by co-pilot

Captain Smit Machchhar is being celebrated worldwide after he was stabbed by his co-pilot and still opened the cockpit door, but outlets differ on details of the attacker's intent and the exact number of people saved.

Analysis deskEditor Andersson Iyke
24 outlets, 9 regions
ShareWhatsAppXLinkedInTelegramFacebookImage

What happened

Captain Smit Machchhar, an Indian national flying a Flydubai Boeing 737 from Dubai to Tel Aviv, was stabbed by his co-pilot mid-air and suffered serious injuries.1379111820

Despite his injuries, Machchhar managed to open or unlock the cockpit door, allowing crew and passengers to overpower the attacker.51011152022

The flight was diverted and made an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia, with all 174 people aboard landing safely.18202324

Machchhar was later moved from a hospital in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, to Abu Dhabi for continued medical treatment, and was reported to be in good health and recovering.918

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu publicly praised Machchhar, with Modi calling him a hero and crediting him with showing the highest form of courage.6172123

What's agreed

Reported consistently by outlets in more than one region.

  • Captain Smit Machchhar is an Indian national who was captain of the Flydubai flight.24
  • Machchhar was stabbed by his co-pilot during the flight to Tel Aviv.137
  • Machchhar opened the cockpit door while being attacked, allowing others to intervene.51520
  • The flight made an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia.1823
  • Narendra Modi praised Machchhar as a hero.61723
  • Machchhar is from India and has been widely referred to as a hero in coverage of the incident.1019

Where accounts differ

Each account is attributed to who makes it. We do not judge between them.

Nationality of the co-pilot and nature of the attack

The Jerusalem Post and The Times of India, citing officials

The co-pilot is described as Omani and the attack is reported as an alleged assault in the cockpit.520

The Straits Times, citing Netanyahu

The incident is described as an alleged attempt to crash the plane, not just a physical assault.21

The Kathmandu Post

The co-pilot is reported to have attacked Machchhar and attempted to crash the jet, described as a reported account.24

Number of people saved or aboard the flight

Several outlets including South China Morning Post and The National

174 lives or passengers are cited as having been saved or aboard.1022182024

Clarín

Approximately 170 people are cited as saved.12

The New York Times

Around 170 people on board are cited as saved.19

Where Machchhar was first treated

Arab News

Machchhar was initially taken to hospital in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, before being moved to Abu Dhabi.18

How it's framed

What each perspective puts first, based on headlines and summaries.

PerspectiveHow it readsWhat it puts first
Indian outletsSouth AsiaIndian coverage emphasizes national pride, Modi's praise, and detailed personal and professional background of Machchhar, including his prior career plans and flying history.8162023national pride, Modi's statements, pilot's biography, hero framing
Middle Eastern outletsMiddle East & TurkeyOutlets based in Israel, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the UAE focus on the pilot's recovery, his movement between hospitals, and statements from regional leaders including Netanyahu, alongside his personal reflections on passenger safety.513182122hospital transfer, regional leaders' praise, passenger safety, recovery
Western public broadcasters and major outletsEuropeThe BBC and Financial Times center on Machchhar's own account of events and the sequence of the cockpit struggle, with relatively restrained tone compared to some other coverage.311pilot's firsthand account, sequence of events, crew and passenger cooperation
North American outletsNorth AmericaUS outlets such as Fox News, The Washington Post and The New York Times emphasize Modi's commentary, personal background including his shift from a family textile business to aviation, and the scale of lives saved.61419political statements, personal backstory, heroism narrative
State-controlled outletsRussia & EurasiaTASS, a Russian state-controlled outlet, focuses narrowly on confirming the pilot's identity and professional history, citing Indian media as its source, with minimal editorializing.2identity confirmation, sourcing from Indian press, factual minimalism
Southeast Asian and East Asian outletsSoutheast AsiaCNA and The Straits Times, as well as South China Morning Post, highlight diplomatic and health updates alongside international reactions such as Netanyahu's statement.92110diplomatic statements, health updates, international reactions
Latin American outletsLatin AmericaFolha de S.Paulo and Clarín focus on identifying the pilot for their audiences and summarizing the heroic framing already established in other coverage.412pilot identification, heroic framing, summary for new audience

What the coverage leaves out

  • None of the outlets reviewed reported the co-pilot's motive or any statement from the co-pilot himself.
  • None of the outlets reviewed detailed the current legal status or formal charges against the co-pilot beyond his being in custody, as reported by The Times of India.
  • None of the outlets reviewed gave full details of the findings of the investigations by Saudi, UAE, and Israeli authorities, which are described as ongoing.
  • None of the outlets reviewed clarified the discrepancy between figures of 174 and approximately 170 people aboard the flight.

Why it matters

The flight was operated by Flydubai between Dubai and Tel Aviv, a route connecting the UAE and Israel.1820

Captain Machchhar had reportedly logged nearly 9,750 flying hours and previously worked at SpiceJet before joining Flydubai.2324

What to watch

  • Outcomes of the ongoing investigations by Saudi, UAE, and Israeli authorities into the incident.
  • Updates on Captain Machchhar's medical recovery following his transfer to Abu Dhabi.
  • Potential legal proceedings against the co-pilot, who is reported to be in custody.

Sources (24)

Every outlet we drew on, grouped by where it is based. Read the originals for the full reporting.

Latin America

ShareWhatsAppXLinkedInTelegramFacebookImage

More in World

Get every side of the day's news.

Join the list for our daily briefing, launching soon.