Skip to content
World edition
Analyst Newspaper
Climate · Multi-perspective analysis

Turkey-Australia joint leadership of COP31 draws scrutiny ahead of summit

Turkey and Australia's shared leadership of the COP31 summit, set for next month in Turkey, has drawn both preparatory diplomacy and public skepticism, with outlets differing on how smoothly the arrangement is working and what it will deliver.

Analysis deskEditor Andersson IykeUpdated
18 outlets, 7 regions

What happened

COP31, the UN climate summit, is set to take place next month in Turkey, with Turkey and Australia sharing leadership of the conference.36718

Pre-COP talks were held in Fiji and Tuvalu, where Pacific leaders and Turkish officials discussed warming limits, climate finance and ocean protection.61810

Coverage includes reports of public demonstrations for climate action, questions about the fossil fuel agenda, and concerns about inclusiveness raised by a Tuvalu official and residents of Australia's Cocos (Keeling) Islands.38145

RTÉ News reported that the joint Turkey-Australia leadership structure has raised doubts, particularly among EU observers, about the summit's capacity to produce concrete outcomes.15

Public demonstrations have called for stronger climate action ahead of COP31, including a large march in Brussels.3

What's agreed

Reported consistently by outlets in more than one region.

  • COP31, the UN Climate Change Conference, is scheduled to be held next month in Turkey (variously referred to as Antalya), with Turkey and Australia sharing leadership roles.3671815
  • Pre-COP talks were held in Fiji (Nadi) and Tuvalu, bringing together Pacific leaders and officials ahead of the main summit.61810
  • Climate finance and adaptation funding remain key concerns, with multiple voices saying current financing is insufficient.116
  • Questions have been raised about the inclusiveness of COP31-related processes for smaller or remote territories and nations.514

Where accounts differ

Each account is attributed to who makes it. We do not judge between them.

Whether Australia's role in pre-COP proceedings in the Pacific was appropriate or overreaching

Unnamed Tuvalu official, via Taipei Times

A Tuvalu official said Australia 'took over' during a pre-COP visit, implying Australia dominated the proceedings.14

Anadolu Agency (Turkish state media)

Reported neutrally that Turkey's environment minister held trilateral talks with Australia's Climate Change Minister Bowen and UN climate chief Stiell as part of routine preparatory diplomacy.11

Whether fossil fuel phase-out will be addressed at COP31

Punch (Nigerian privately owned outlet)

Reports that fossil fuels are off the COP31 agenda despite a 2023 pledge to transition away from them, while global production keeps rising.8

The Guardian, citing COP31 president-designate Murat Kurum

Reports that Kurum hedged on whether countries should repeat the prior agreement to transition away from fossil fuels, rather than ruling it out entirely.10

Overall confidence in COP31's joint Turkey-Australia leadership to deliver results

RTÉ News, citing EU sentiment

Describes a 'fragile' moment for climate diplomacy, with the unique joint leadership arrangement raising doubts about the summit's ability to deliver concrete results.15

Anadolu Agency (Turkish state media)

Portrays preparations as proceeding through structured, cooperative talks between Turkish and Australian officials and the UN climate chief.11

How it's framed

What each perspective puts first, based on headlines and summaries.

PerspectiveHow it readsWhat it puts first
Turkish state mediaMiddle East & TurkeyAnadolu Agency frames COP31 preparations as orderly multilateral diplomacy, highlighting cooperative talks between Turkey, Australia and the UN.11trilateral talks, preparatory cooperation, Action Agenda
European outlets (public broadcasters and private press)EuropeEuropean coverage is more skeptical, questioning the joint Turkey-Australia leadership structure and the host's stance on fossil fuels, alongside reporting on public pressure through protests and EU strategy documents.1510313doubts over leadership, fossil fuel ambiguity, public mobilization, EU strategy
Pacific and Oceania-adjacent coverageOceaniaHighlights concerns from Pacific and Australian remote territories about exclusion or domination within COP31-related processes, alongside Pacific leaders' own climate priorities.51814exclusion, Pacific priorities, rising seas, forgotten territories
African climate negotiators and pressAfricaAfrican outlets emphasize unmet climate finance and adaptation commitments and call for trust-building in the multilateral process, with one outlet also noting the gap between fossil fuel pledges and rising production.18climate finance, adaptation funding, trust in multilateral process, fossil fuel production rising
Southeast and South Asian outletsSoutheast AsiaCoverage focuses on national interests at COP31, such as Indonesia seeking green investment and the EU's emissions-cutting push, alongside neutral reporting on pre-COP talks.7136green investment, international partnerships, emissions cuts package
East Asian outletsEast AsiaCoverage ranges from China's state media promoting its own climate cooperation messaging to concerns about deadlock in the underlying climate science process.92climate cooperation, scientific deadlock
Middle East-based outletsMiddle East & TurkeyGulf-based and Turkish-focused coverage includes both state-controlled framing of nature restoration themes and independent reporting on domestic civil society concerns about crackdowns around COP31.41617nature restoration, adaptation urgency, civil society crackdown fears

What the coverage leaves out

  • None of the outlets reviewed detailed the specific structure or division of responsibilities in the Turkey-Australia joint COP31 leadership arrangement.
  • None of the outlets reviewed reported a direct response from Australian officials to the Tuvalu official's claim that Australia 'took over' the pre-COP visit.
  • None of the outlets reviewed specified what, if any, alternative fossil fuel language COP31's president-designate might propose in place of the 'transition away' pledge.
  • None of the outlets reviewed detailed what specific actions or measures the African Group of Negotiators wants on finance and adaptation beyond general calls to honor commitments.

Why it matters

COP31 comes at a moment when the UN Environment Programme and climate scientists have warned that global efforts to limit warming are falling short, raising the stakes for what the summit can achieve.122

A 2023 pledge to transition away from fossil fuels has not been matched by falling production, with oil, gas and coal output continuing to rise, according to Punch.8

What to watch

  • Whether COP31 negotiations address a renewed commitment to transition away from fossil fuels, given the host's hedging noted by The Guardian.
  • Outcomes of the EU's push for an emissions-reduction 'package' at COP31, as previewed by The Straits Times.
  • Whether concerns raised by Pacific and remote Australian territory representatives about inclusion are addressed before or during the summit.

Sources (18)

Every outlet we drew on, grouped by where it is based. Read the originals for the full reporting.

Oceania

Get every side of the day's news.

Join the list for our daily briefing, launching soon.