Skip to content
World edition
Analyst Newspaper
World · Multi-perspective analysis

Pakistan strikes 10 sites in Afghanistan after drone attacks

Pakistan says it struck ten Afghan sites in retaliation for drone attacks from across the border; accounts diverge on casualties, and the Taliban disputes Pakistan's account of the initial drone attack.

Analysis deskEditor Andersson Iyke
12 outlets, 4 regions

What happened

Pakistan's Information Minister Attaullah Tarar said Pakistani forces struck 10 locations in Afghanistan used to launch and store drones, calling the strikes deliberate, precise, calibrated and proportionate.345910

Pakistan said the strikes were retaliation for drone attacks launched from Afghanistan a day earlier; according to Pakistani officials cited by NDTV, security forces intercepted drones before they reached Kohat and Torkham.7910

A Taliban government spokesman denied Pakistan's version of events and said the strikes killed four civilians in southern and eastern Afghanistan; Anadolu Agency separately reported four people killed, without specifying civilian status, while a provincial governor's office said strikes in Khost caused no casualties.238

According to Arab News, the strikes occur against a backdrop of rising tension between Pakistan and Afghanistan's Taliban government, including mutual accusations over cross-border militancy and the countries' worst fighting in years in February.610

What's agreed

Reported consistently by outlets in more than one region.

  • Pakistan launched air strikes on 10 locations inside Afghanistan.123456789101112
  • Pakistan said the strikes were retaliation for drone attacks launched from Afghanistan a day earlier.25910
  • Pakistani Information Minister Attaullah Tarar described the strikes as deliberate, precise, calibrated and proportionate, and limited to military objectives linked to the attempted attacks.349

Where accounts differ

Each account is attributed to who makes it. We do not judge between them.

Whether the strikes caused civilian deaths

Taliban government, via France 24

A Taliban government spokesman said Pakistan's strikes killed four civilians in Afghanistan's southern and eastern provinces.2

Anadolu Agency

Reported four people killed in the airstrikes, without specifying civilian status.3

Governor's office in Khost, via Al Jazeera

Said strikes carried out in Khost province caused no casualties.8

Pakistan's justification for retaliation

Pakistan, via TASS, Dawn, Arab News, RT

Afghan drones entered Pakistani airspace and were used to attack Pakistan, justifying retaliatory strikes on the launch and storage sites.15910

Pakistani officials, via NDTV

Security forces neutralized eight rudimentary drones allegedly launched by the Afghan Taliban before they reached Kohat and Torkham.7

Taliban government spokesman, via France 24

Denied that Pakistan's strikes were a genuine retaliation for a drone attack on a border post.2

Whether Afghanistan harbours anti-Pakistan militants

Islamabad, via Jerusalem Post and Arab News

Accuses Kabul of harbouring militants who stage cross-border attacks against Pakistan.610

Afghanistan's Taliban government, via Jerusalem Post

Denies harbouring anti-Pakistani insurgents.6

How it's framed

What each perspective puts first, based on headlines and summaries.

PerspectiveHow it readsWhat it puts first
Pakistani state and Pakistan-based outletsSouth AsiaCoverage centers on the Information Minister's framing of the strikes as a lawful, proportionate act of self-defence against drone launch and storage sites.4911sovereign right to self-defence, precision, calibrated response
State-controlled Russian outletsRussia & EurasiaRT and TASS report the strikes largely through Pakistan's official statements, describing targets as drone launchpads or storage sites; these reports do not include Afghan casualty claims.15drone launchpads, official Pakistani statements
Middle East-based outletsMiddle East & TurkeyAnadolu Agency, Al Jazeera and Jerusalem Post report both the strikes and the wider Pakistan-Afghanistan tension, including denials from the Taliban and disputed casualty figures.36810proportionality claims, denials by Taliban, harbouring accusation
European public broadcasterEuropeFrance 24 foregrounds the Taliban's civilian casualty claim and its denial of Pakistan's retaliation narrative, presenting a more contested account than other outlets.2civilian casualties, Taliban denial
Indian privately owned outletsSouth AsiaThe Hindu, NDTV and Economic Times report the strikes primarily through Pakistani official statements and details of the alleged drone incursion, with limited elaboration on Afghan reaction.4712ministerial statements, drone incursion details

What the coverage leaves out

  • None of the outlets reviewed provided independent verification of casualty figures beyond attributed statements from Pakistani officials, the Taliban government, or a provincial governor's office.
  • None of the outlets reviewed detailed the identity or affiliation of those allegedly operating the drones beyond general reference to Afghan Taliban forces.
  • None of the outlets reviewed reported reaction from countries other than Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Why it matters

The strikes come amid escalating tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan's Taliban government over cross-border militant attacks, which the countries' worst fighting in years in February also stemmed from, according to Arab News.10

Sources (12)

Every outlet we drew on, grouped by where it is based. Read the originals for the full reporting.

More in World

Get every side of the day's news.

Join the list for our daily briefing, launching soon.